Obstructed Views, Inching Out, and Being Waved Through: Who Is Responsible When the Next Lane Is Hidden?
Published .
When the Driver Cannot See From the Stop Line
A parked truck, hedge, or queue of stopped vehicles can hide approaching traffic. A driver may need to edge forward to gain a view. The danger arises when the driver must put part of the vehicle into a travel lane before seeing what is coming. In Creaser v. Owens, the Court rejected the proposition that limited visibility relieved an unfavored driver of the duty to yield. Moving at a crawl may improve the ability to stop, but the driver still must account for the traffic the obstruction conceals.
What a Wave Communicates
Consider a driver turning left from a shopping center. A stopped driver leaves a gap in the near lane and waves. The turning driver crosses that lane and is hit in the next one. The important questions are what the gesture reasonably meant, what the signaling driver could see, and whether the entering driver could independently check the next lane.
In Dix v. Spampinato, a pedestrian passed in front of a stopped vehicle after a signal from its driver and was struck in the adjoining lane. Maryland’s highest court concluded on those facts that the gesture conveyed permission to pass in front of the signaling vehicle. A claim that someone undertook to direct a person across another lane requires evidence of what the person actually communicated and why reliance on that broader direction was reasonable.
Examining the Approaching Driver’s Conduct
The approaching driver may have been traveling lawfully, passing on a shoulder, entering a turn lane prematurely, or driving too fast to react to gaps in traffic. Reconstruct each lane separately. A camera showing the approach to the gap may establish where the vehicles first came into each other’s view, even if no recording captures the wave.
Related Maryland Cases and Authorities
Creaser v. Owens, 267 Md. 238 (1972), and Grady v. Brown, 408 Md. 182 (2009), on the duty to yield and causation.
Dix v. Spampinato, 278 Md. 34 (1976), on the scope of a motorist’s signal.
