Mass Transit Accidents in Maryland: Outside Drivers, Injured Passengers, and Too Little Insurance
Published .
Who Caused the Passenger to Fall?
A passenger can be thrown to the floor without the bus striking anything. A car may turn left across its path, forcing hard braking. The transit operator may have had time to recognize the danger earlier, or the emergency stop may have been the safest available response. Investigate the outside motorist and the operator separately. The forward-facing video can show the turn, the plate, and the time available to respond. The interior video can show where passengers were positioned, what they were holding, and when they fell. The route, direction, vehicle number, stop, and time help identify the correct footage.
Ordinary Movement and Unusual Force
Kaufman v. Baltimore Transit Co. and Washington Metropolitan Area Transit Authority v. Djan distinguish ordinary incidents of transit travel from evidence supporting carrier negligence. Saying the bus “jerked violently” is less useful than explaining that several people were thrown or that a passenger holding a rail was displaced across the aisle. Djan also explains that an operator ordinarily need not wait for a passenger to sit before starting, although an obvious disability can affect the duty. In a collision or evasive-stop case, the evidence must explain both the force of the movement and why it occurred.
One Driver, Many Passengers, and a $60,000 Fund
Maryland’s ordinary minimum bodily-injury liability limits are $30,000 per person and $60,000 per accident for two or more people. If the only at-fault driver carries those limits, the $60,000 can be the entire liability fund for the injured passengers and anyone else injured in the same occurrence. Eight claimants sharing the fund equally would receive $7,500 each before expenses or liens. That arithmetic illustrates the shortfall. It does not establish the proper allocation. A passenger with surgery and permanent impairment, a passenger who needed only brief treatment, and an occupant whose injuries are disputed may each assert a different share.
Global Settlement and Interpleader
A global settlement can allocate the available proceeds if the necessary parties agree on the claims, shares, and releases. When there are competing demands, an insurer may use Maryland Rule 2-221 to seek interpleader in circuit court and ask the court to determine entitlement to the fund. Review the amount deposited, any requested discharge, the proposed treatment of fees and costs, and whether the insurer seeks relief affecting claims beyond the deposited proceeds. The fund can be distributed only once. Separate claims and deadlines should be tracked independently while the allocation is pending. See also Interpleader Actions in Maryland.
Each Passenger’s Own Insurance Can Change the Outcome
Review each passenger’s auto and applicable household policies. For standard Maryland UM/UIM, § 19-509(a)(2)(ii) accounts for liability limits reduced by payments to other people arising from the same occurrence. Obtain the payment history and remaining limits along with the declarations. Connors v. Government Employees Insurance Co. shows how the insureds’ own standard UIM per-accident limit and the tortfeasor’s payments can affect the calculation when two insureds claim under one policy. Standard UIM and enhanced UIM have different payment and settlement rules. For standard UIM, check § 19-511 before accepting a written offer that, together with other settlements, would exhaust the applicable liability coverage.
PIP is a separate inquiry. Maryland excludes statutory buses and taxicabs from the definition of “motor vehicle” for the relevant insurance subtitle. In Maryland Insurance Administration v. State Farm, the Court explained that § 19-513(d)(1)(i) is directed in part at insureds injured while occupying buses or taxis on which statutory PIP is not in effect. Examine the passenger’s own insured status, waiver, limits, and deadline. Two people sitting next to each other on the same bus may have markedly different sources of recovery.
Preserving a Claim Against the Transit Operator
Identify the actual carrier early. For an MTA claim governed by Transp. § 7-702, the statute generally requires written notice to the Administrator or designee within one year after the injury, denial of the claim, and suit within three years after the cause of action arises. Investigating the outside motorist can take months, which makes it important to address MTA notice while operator fault is still being examined. WMATA operates under an interstate compact. Tinsley explains the compact’s distinction between proprietary and governmental functions for immunity purposes. County and private services require their own analysis.
The Misery at the End of the Case
The worst part may come after the passenger proves what happened. An injured person can establish clear fault, undergo surgery, and still collect a small fraction of the loss. That can happen when the outside driver has minimum limits and few collectible assets, several other people have valid claims, the transit operator has no provable fault, and the passenger has little applicable UIM. A judgment can establish the amount owed while leaving much of it uncollected.
Even the allocated share can overstate what the passenger takes home. Case expenses, fees under the engagement agreement, and enforceable liens or reimbursement claims can reduce the net. Explain three figures early: the value of the injury, the amount likely to be collected, and the amount the client may actually receive. In a crowded-bus case, the hardest outcome is often a strong claim against a driver who cannot pay what the injury is worth.
Related Maryland Cases and Authorities
Kaufman v. Baltimore Transit Co., 197 Md. 141 (1951), and Washington Metropolitan Area Transit Authority v. Djan, on passenger falls, jolts, and carrier conduct.
Tinsley v. Washington Metropolitan Area Transit Authority and Md. Code, Transp. § 7-702, on the separate WMATA and MTA frameworks.
Connors v. Government Employees Insurance Co., 442 Md. 466 (2015), and Maryland Insurance Administration v. State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Co., on UIM limits and personal-policy PIP, respectively.
Maryland Rule 2-221, Md. Code, Transp. § 17-103, and Ins. §§ 19-509, 19-509.1, and 19-511.
