Taxicab, Uber, and Other For-Hire Transportation Accidents: Who Is Responsible and What Insurance Applies?

Published .

Start With the Trip and the Actual Operator

A passenger injured in a taxicab, an Uber or Lyft, an airport shuttle, or a hired sedan may have claims against the driver, a separate vehicle owner or carrier, or another motorist. Start by identifying who was driving, who owned the vehicle, who arranged the trip, and who was responsible for operating the service. A company name on a receipt is useful evidence. The receipt, vehicle registration, dispatch records, and agreements may identify different entities with different roles. Maryland law distinguishes taxicab, transportation network, sedan, and limousine services.

When the For-Hire Driver Is at Fault

A paying passenger has no control over how the driver approaches an intersection, follows traffic, or chooses a stopping point. If a driver runs a red light or strikes a car stopped ahead, the central inquiry is how the driver's conduct caused the passenger’s injuries. If another driver also contributed, develop both accounts before deciding which parties and policies belong in the case. A passenger may also be injured during boarding or unloading. In that setting, the immediate questions are who selected the location, when the driver knew the passenger was getting in or out, and whether the vehicle began moving or a door opened into traffic.

In St. Michelle v. Catania, Maryland’s highest court addressed a taxicab carrier’s responsibilities to a fare-paying passenger in a case involving an assault. The conduct there was intentional, but the decision is useful for identifying the relationship between a taxi carrier and its passenger. Washington Metropolitan Area Transit Authority v. Seymour discusses the heightened duty of a common carrier more broadly. Whether a particular defendant owed that duty, and what it required during the specific phase of the trip, should be analyzed from the facts. An app booking alone does not resolve whether the platform is liable for the driver’s negligence.

In an Uber or Lyft Case, Establish the App Status at the Moment of Impact

The driver's activity immediately before the crash can determine which coverage applies. Distinguish a driver who was offline, one logged on and available for requests, one who had accepted a ride and was driving to the pickup, and one transporting a passenger. A driver can be on an accepted trip even though the passenger has not yet entered the vehicle. The app can also record exactly when a ride was canceled or completed. Obtain those records when the collision happened near a pickup or drop-off.

Maryland Public Utilities § 10-405 sets insurance requirements during covered transportation network services. The statute specifies bodily-injury liability security of at least $50,000 per person and $100,000 for two or more persons, $25,000 for property damage, and the UM and PIP coverage called for by the referenced Maryland insurance statutes. The actual policy may provide higher limits or different benefits by trip phase. Obtain the declarations and endorsements in effect on the crash date before quoting a platform limit to a client. Also identify any commercial or rideshare endorsement maintained by the driver. Section 10-405 addresses priority and what the company’s coverage must provide in specified circumstances when operator coverage is not in force.

When Another Driver Causes the Crash

A passenger may initially look to the outside driver's liability insurance. If that policy is inadequate, the next question is whether the passenger qualifies for UM/UIM under the trip policy, a personal or household policy, or another applicable source. Check the insured-person definition, policy priority, and both per-person and per-accident limits. Several passengers in the same vehicle can be competing for a limited liability fund while each has different UM/UIM protection. A substantial liability limit on the for-hire vehicle does not establish that the same amount is available in UM/UIM.

Taxicab PIP requires separate attention. Maryland excludes statutory taxicabs from the definition of “motor vehicle” in the relevant Insurance Article subtitle. In Maryland Insurance Administration v. State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Co., the Court addressed a personal-policy PIP claim involving a taxicab and explained how § 19-513(d)(1)(i) can apply when an insured occupies a vehicle on which statutory PIP is not in effect. Check the passenger’s personal or household coverage, insured status, and any applicable waiver or exclusion. For an app-based trip, examine the transportation network policy under its own statutory and contractual framework.

Related Maryland Cases and Authorities

St. Michelle v. Catania, 252 Md. 647 (1969), and Washington Metropolitan Area Transit Authority v. Seymour, on common-carrier duties.

Md. Code, Pub. Util. §§ 10-101 and 10-405, on for-hire service classifications and transportation network coverage.

Maryland Insurance Administration v. State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Co., and Md. Code, Ins. §§ 19-501 and 19-513, on personal PIP and taxicabs.

Connors v. Government Employees Insurance Co., 442 Md. 466 (2015), on standard UIM and the per-accident limit.

Contact The Belsky Law Firm