Accidents With Emergency Response Vehicles: Lights, Sirens, Right of Way, and Immunity

Published .

The Duties at an Intersection

A qualifying emergency driver may proceed past a red light or stop sign after slowing as necessary for safety. Statutory signaling requirements and the duty to drive with due regard for safety still matter. Other motorists must yield on the immediate approach of a qualifying emergency or police vehicle using the prescribed signals. An ordinary driver’s green light does not settle what the driver reasonably could have seen or heard. An emergency driver’s siren does not settle whether the vehicle entered a blind intersection too fast.

Direct Collisions and Police Pursuits

Khawaja v. City of Rockville arose from a collision with a police cruiser. It helps distinguish the operator’s position from that of the government owner. Boyer v. State involved a high-speed pursuit during which the pursued motorist caused a fatal collision. A pursuit case adds questions about how the pursuit began and continued and how the pursued driver’s conduct contributed to the impact. In either case, obtain dispatch records, vehicle data, video, and independent accounts of when lights and siren became perceptible.

Who May Be Sued?

Apply Transp. § 19-103 and Cts. & Jud. Proc. § 5-639 separately to the authorized operator and the owner or lessee. The operator has individual immunity for ordinary negligence while performing statutory emergency service, with exceptions for malice and gross negligence. The owner or lessee may be liable under the statute for an authorized operator’s ordinary negligence, subject to applicable limits. That statutory owner-liability provision excludes the operator’s gross negligence and malice. Identify the owner, the mission at the time of the collision, and the applicable notice requirements before choosing the defendant and theory.

Related Maryland Cases and Authorities

Khawaja v. City of Rockville, 89 Md. App. 314 (1991), and Boyer v. State, 323 Md. 558 (1991).

Md. Code, Transp. §§ 19-103, 21-106, and 21-405, and Cts. & Jud. Proc. § 5-639.

Contact The Belsky Law Firm