Traveling on the Shoulder: Passing Stopped Traffic, Reentering a Lane, and Striking Disabled Vehicles
Published .
When Passing on the Shoulder Is Permitted
Maryland generally defines the roadway to exclude the shoulder. Section 21-304 permits passing on the right only under specified conditions and only when safe. For motorists, the paved shoulder exception is narrow. A driver may use it to pass a vehicle making or about to make a left turn if the pass can be made safely and without leaving the paved surface. A paved shoulder does not ordinarily provide a lane to bypass a line of stopped traffic or reach a distant exit. The statute separately addresses bicycle and motor-scooter operators. If signs or lane-control signals authorize travel in a particular shoulder at certain times, establish what the controls displayed when the crash occurred.
What Rosenthal v. Mueller Adds
In Rosenthal, a driver tried to pass to the right of a stopped truck that was signaling left. The following motorist came over a hill and around a blind curve, swerved toward the guardrail, and struck the passing car. The appellate court held that the evidence was insufficient to submit the passing driver’s contributory negligence to the jury. Even assuming she was negligent in using the shoulder, the evidence had to show how that conduct contributed to the accident. The court distinguished the following motorist’s attempt to stop by hitting the guardrail from an attempt to use the shoulder as a travel lane. Apply today’s version of § 21-304 to the legality of a pass and Rosenthal to the separate causation inquiry.
Reentry, Breakdowns, and the Move-Over Duty
A driver pulling away from the shoulder must determine that entry into the travel lane is safe. A signal warns through traffic, but the entering driver still needs a reasonable gap. Conversely, a through driver approaching a qualifying stopped vehicle displaying the required warning signals must comply with Maryland’s move-over rule. Where a safe lane change is unavailable, the statute calls for slowing to a reasonable and prudent speed. Determine whether the struck vehicle was entirely on the shoulder, partly in the lane, or already moving back into traffic. Also establish what warning signals were visible and how far away an approaching driver could see them.
The strongest proof often comes from footage showing where the solid edge line was crossed, how far the shoulder driver traveled, and whether the driver was passing, stopping, or reentering. Photograph the shoulder width, any pavement drop-off, and the sight line around a curve. A collision involving a car that traveled down the shoulder for 300 feet presents different choices and warning time from one involving a two-second evasive move.
Related Maryland Cases and Authorities
Rosenthal v. Mueller, 124 Md. App. 170 (1998), on shoulder use and causation.
Md. Code, Transp. §§ 11-151, 21-304, 21-309, 21-405, 21-604, and 21-1001.
